Wednesday, June 5, 2019

Mother in law - Foe not Friend!!?



At a social group meeting held on the eve of this year’s international women’s day, I was pained as I was unpleasantly surprised at how some of the sociocultural narratives are stuck in archaic grooves.
Young women, even those from well educated families, are still grappling with tyrannical or for the very least over bearing and demanding mothers in law. One would have otherwise blissfully surmised that investing in the educational status of families helps revise social norms for the better.
This reality has to be put to closer deeper scrutiny.
It is about patriarchal mindsets. It is about role definitions. It is about men passing their own responsibilities as sons over to the wives. The latter being open receptacles, ever willing to receive whatever gets put in there, get filled up to the brim and beyond. It is a societal scam.
Women are put on the pedestal. They are epitomes of kindness, personifications of giving, worthy of worship and it goes on and on. All kinds of flowery adjectives are available to keep them on the tow. It is exploitative.
Why does society insist upon adoption of another set of parents? Why does society demand shifting of priorities from original biological parents to parents in law? Why should a child in law look after parents in law?
High time these questions be dared. High time some terrifying truths be unraveled.
A closer look shows you it is invariably the female child by law, the daughter in law, here as well as there who is expected to bear the burden of looking after the ‘new’ parents. Each time it is a daughter in law who is burdened. This daughter will go look after his parents there as the daughter in law. The other daughter will come in and become the daughter here and do the same.
Now, in a well-balanced, albeit utopian, society it would work just fine. A daughter from here through exogamy goes there takes over and/or adopts household home family parents. Another daughter from another home comes over and does just the same. In a patrilocal society, where the woman moves to the husband’s place, there is a lot of wisdom in adopting this pattern. The adoption of family household responsibilities helps integrate the new comer into the new family.  If it was taken up with that well intended spirit, there would be equal and fair sharing of roles by all household members. How is that even imaginable if the household was already steeped in gender bias! If the original daughter and her mother were bearing all the burden. Hence what happens is actually a transfer of responsibilities and burdens as symbolized in the boy’s mother handing over of  keys to the boy’s wife, the new entrant, the daughter in law, embraced with open arms as the daughter who will now take over. It stinks! 
Recalling a chat with my son:
“Mom whom would you much rather have you be looked after by. Me or my wife?”
 “Of course you!”
And that was it. Very simple. This equation needs to be put to discussion when a couple is planning a life together and before tying the knot.
What about those who are in the unfair messed up situation that is heavily skewed in favor of the matriarch? Men have to rise up as responsible caring fair partners. Let us heave praises on them when they do. Place them on the, not so vied for, pedestal. It is time women stepped down from there.
Society has to start looking toward how the men/boys are faring. Move the spotlight away from daughters in law and beam it onto the sons. Let us as a society start demanding from our sons that they look after their parents themselves and thus deliver on their responsibilities towards their parents directly rather than by imposing the same upon their wives. Let us free the daughters in law to take care of their own parents.
From that vantage point we could then hope to look at the emergence of a mutually supportive equal spousal partnerships. A prerequisite for ‘happy’ and fulfilled families/society.

Monday, October 1, 2018

Arriving at the Rainbow of Life – my jaan’s 1st wedding anniversary!


What is it that I am feeling? Is this happiness? I don’t know but I feel okay. What is that supposed to mean? And why is that important? It seems important for me to be able to put some value to how my non normative way of life has faired. Ignoring norms, mostly, I followed my urge my instinct my something that I am yet to put a finger on. I think it has been about following what I believe in. Before I endorse or celebrate this way of living life it is important to be able to reflect upon where it has got me, so far. And far it is! Can one ever claim it was THE right WAY? Given the numerous variables involved and the impossibility of a case control study on my/any life, one cannot. Hence no claims, desired or not, to righteousness. Analysing a way of life can never be about a statistical analysis but simply about whether or not it feels right and thus totally subjective. With that disclaimer and the reiteration that one is not preaching a way of living a life, I would like to introspect and share. Indulge me! 
So, where am I? Some of the world might see me as someone left out in the cold. With kids out of the nest and the entrepreneur husband immersed in his start up. Nobody really needs me and strangely enough, that’s what is solace for me. Or is it a sense of accomplishment? Or perhaps a sense of meaningful culmination? Both my original kids and both the by law kids all on their own. Settled? I don’t know about that. It’s a definition still pending. And I will get to it but for now it suffices to say and to know that I am celebrating their being in the real world and not in the protected world under my wings. So unreal that had felt. And so scary with its potential to come crashing down on us. Well, they are where they are amidst their respective lives struggles joys celebrations disappointments achievements. A healthy mix.
What about me? Oh I am loving where I am and how my life is. A rich blend of large swathes of personal space and a fulfilling companionship interspersed with professional or domestic chores and dotted with quality conversations with kids. A predictable pattern. Then there is time with few time tested friends over cups of coffee and few other occasions. Some family bonds are visited every once in a while.
Personal time, precious as it is, is ever expanding occupying more and more space and more and more centrality. Regular work on the body, its maintenance and upkeep, the muscle strengthening exercises, the brisk walks, healthy diet, skin hair dental care.  The mind needs its regular de cluttering. Keeps it crisp and clean. Staying tuned in to the feeling heart. Treating it to music books plants movies pets on its asking and calling. Keeps it warm and throbbing. All a celebration of health.
Life with all its colors is beginning to appear and feel like a solid stable rainbow and not any more the dark grey clouds playing hide and seek with streaks of sunlight. Lurking somewhere close behind is the fear of the transience of this rainbow. But then there is some inner strength holding a promise that it` will withstand the clouds well knowing that transience will prevail yet again. The rainbow of life is a beautifully arranged array of colors.  Amidst these is the joyful yellow or is it orange. Sheer joy when it is just me and the music and I get up and sway and swing and move to the beats. All by myself. Being on my own, the solitude, has been a yet another joy. So pure and serene. Is it the white? The background for all colors to glow and show. Or perhaps the platform for a stellar celebration!
How did I get here? The process of scrutiny reflection introspection or whatever continues. But before that there is much more to be understood and spoken about where I am. I know that within me.


Wednesday, September 26, 2018

Learning to Let Go - Target for the 7th Decade Fixed!!


Sailing ? Walking? No, hobbling into 7th decade!!
I expected different because I believe I have looked after myself well during previous decade. Live well during this decade to have healthy next decade is after all the wellness mantra!
No surprise there that life has sprung a surprise on me! Yet it has surprised me and the surprise is trying hard to pull me down. It has managed to do so to some extent but with help from self and few others around I have stayed afloat.
Contrary to dancing and gliding into 7th decade I couldn’t even walk straight into it. My left leg will tell you why but that is not the point here. The point is whether or not I learnt well to ‘let go’. Apparently I have still some way to go....perhaps a long way yet.
There is an equation that I have often alluded to when addressing apprehensions, mine or theirs, and it has held me in good stead.
In that equation, A + B = R, the result, A is one’s own Actions and B the factor/s Beyond one’s control. Hence the equation makes 2 essential points. There can be no R without A hence the need to act. Also and as importantly the need to realize there is a ‘Beyond one’s control’ that will also inform the R. One cannot argue with it. One has to accept it. One has to resign to it. One has to surrender, to let go.
I had used the equation most often to motivate my children or my own self or some others who reached out for support to prepare for exams and/or challenges, in school or life. Especially required when disillusioned ones, especially me, would want to give up on trying.  While I would mention the B part of the equation I was not relating to it in its entirety. I was not using the equation to help myself or others let go.
Even while I struggle with putting it into practise I understand and know the B part well. The B component could carry an additive value or a negative one. No matter which of those, the factors beyond one’s control loom large. The angels could pull you up or the demons pull you down. You have neither control nor any advance knowledge of it. Call it ‘karmaa’ or ‘prayers being answered’ or ‘luck’ or whatever it is that will help you surrender to it. The only choice you have is how you label it. Go ahead and choose the most comforting one. The one that your socialisation is able to adapt to and adopt. Life is hence like an ongoing game of snakes and ladders that you have to continue to play and roll the dice because Act you must. You have to. It is not a choice if you are looking towards any R at all. Hence, says Bhagwat Gita, do your karma without attachment to the result.
My left leg has compelled me to allude to the 2nd part of the equation, the B! Even while I looked after myself to the best of my ability, the bone density is not upto the mark. My disappointment writ large and my treating orthopaedics in his very polite way pointed out that I, the achiever the fixer, am unable to accept the result and the fact of my inability to fix. The equation stared me in my face and I realized I was yet to master the B part of it. Learning to Let Go.
One of the targets for the 7th decade fixed!!

Wednesday, December 20, 2017

Values vs Norms - often confused!

A tribute to (my) parents!
I have been feeling something very intense and inexplicable today. I am reminded of something similar on this day so many years ago. I couldn't understand and even as I was struggling with trying to understand what I was feeling right beneath my skin, my eldest nephew had called to give me the shattering news in the most candid words. It had left me trembling and shaking (literally). And then I cried and howled for my mother. For her loss even more than my own. She had always believed she will be the one to go first. That night had seemed one of the longest in my life. But I had to see my mother and when I did at the airport I saw an epitome of strength and courage. That's how I remember her. A strict disciplinarian is how I remember my father. I want to be able to imbibe both of those on top of the very sound value system that I got from them. It is true both my parents were very special human beings but they were humans and hence not infallible. And that's fine with me. God bless their souls.

It is this day, several years ago, that my father undoubtedly left for his heavenly abode, if there is that. He was a conscientious karma yogi. His passing away was testimony to the life he lead. He passed away at the door step of his guru who loved him and whom he revered. He passed away thus after sharing with her, I am told by my sisters who were accompanying him for the visit to the guru’s ashram, that he had no more desire to live. It was as if he knew he was going because he had, oddly enough, asked me to accompany him for the trip. Unfortunately, I had declined since I had visited 'Swamiji' recently.

On the anniversary of his passage the family recalls fondly what he was and in fact what both our parents passed onto us.

As is usually the case, it is a combination of values, socio cultural norms and beliefs, traits and habits. Most importantly, rooted in the strong value system is an inner strength and capacity to differentiate between values and norms. Between traits desirable and not, irrespective of whether or not it came to us fro'm our parents. Personally, I am forever watchful lest I express some of those that I disagree with. And the COURAGE to do so was in part handed down to me by my parents via the sound and solid value system.

That brings me to the truth that revered parents such as they were, they were human. They were very special human beings but were human in every respect and hence not infallible. The ability to see that is the transition from childlike reverence of one’s parent as someone perfect to someone who is an admirable although imperfect package. This holds significance for all but especially for parents who have led exemplary lives witnessed and acknowledged by their children.

They left us with a solid value system that comprises of honesty, hard work, discipline, equal respect and rights for all. Some of this they were unable to put to practise in totality. And that is okay with me but shying away from it is not. Some of these conflicts I was able to understand only after my father passed away but I still had one parent, my mother, to take it up with. For example, while my mother spoke Gandhi to me through my childhood, she had issues accepting non Hindus. Another example being my father upholding patriarchy. The societal norms were so deeply entrenched in them that they did not distinguish between values and norms.

Honesty should translate into living what you believe in. That lends strength to me to challenge and question what my value system does not agree with. Not as a rebel but as a non-normative thinking individual.I think we as a family have evolved by adding more value to the values we received from them. I refer here to how many of us have fearlessly challenged some of the cultural norms that were passed down to us. 

It is important to bring all this out at a time when three generations are standing together paying tribute to them. I believe the best tribute to them would be to carry forward this work of questioning unacceptable norms, even if handed down by them, because they are an antithesis to the values they gave us. In other words the norms have to be seen losing the fight, if any, to values. Finally, I believe it has been a work in progress, undertaken by some of us in my generation, and if taken forward by the following generations it would be a feat in perpetuity.


Thursday, October 27, 2016

Shun? No, Celebrate Sexuality!

Shun? No, Celebrate Sexuality!
Through Diwali, as we light lamps of all the positive life forces let us also acknowledge sexuality as one. Sexual offenses and crimes have cast a dark shadow on sexuality in a way that it is not being regarded as something to be celebrated. If we allow the positive force of sexuality energy and force to come through instead of shunning it the dark cloak of fear and shame that is shrouding it could get lifted. 
There is adequate evidence that societies with more positive and liberal view on sexuality report much lower levels of sexual abuse. In sharp contrast, our societal taboos and controls on sex and sexuality especially vis a vis young people have done us no good. Unfortunately, our own young people have been both perpetrators and victims of sexual aggression.
In my recent passage on women’s/ girls’ sexual empowerment under readers’ responses to the series on ‘Lets talk about Rape’ in Hindustan Times, I make a case for young girls’ affirmative sexuality, their sexual rights and freedom. Reacting to it, a lady friend said she was not comfortable with what such a liberal approach could lead to. Further prodding revealed she was apprehensive about the experience of pleasure that it could result in. I am tempted to re phrase it as ‘taste of sexual pleasure’. Why is our young people’s sexuality so threatening for us when we, the adults, are ourselves sexual. Perhaps an underlying assumption that the young people will not be responsible about their desires once the same are evoked. Like a wildfire lit?
I am reminded of a discussion I had with a group of about 15 or so women workers from a well reputed community based NGO. All women were upwards of 35 years of age and I had been assigned the task of orienting them on adolescent issues. It was necessitated by the fact that children in their care had grown into young adolescents. These women harboured concerns regarding sexuality of adolescents similar to those expressed by my friend. Fears regarding fire in the belly were raised and lack of confidence in adolescents’ sense of responsibility came through loud and clear.
Struggling with the task on hand I had proceeded thus. Who, I had asked, is likely having more sex them or us? There was stunned silence. No surprise there! Who is exercising more restraint in response to sexual urges them or us? Palpable discomfort. Who denies or postpones sexual gratification more often them or us?  All that despite raging hormones. So who is being more responsible? Yet we doubt them. Whose hormones are calling with more intensity? Yet we deny them gratification.
The case is being made for empathy and respect for our young adolescents and their sexuality.  Adolescents go through a multitude of concurrent struggles related to identity hormones rapid growth and bodily changes. Let us not add to their stresses. Instead let us engage with them through open honest communication and support them making informed choices free of duress. An open honest dialogue within and amongst us, the elders, has to necessarily precede it else we or they will trip and fall. We need to confront and deal with our fears rather than burden the young with them.  Most of all we need to acknowledge sexuality per se as a positive life force to be celebrated rather than be dreaded and shunned as something shameful/ sinful.
In tandem we need to ensure our young have the where with all to protect themselves from sexual coercion, infections and other undesirable outcomes of sexual intimacy as also demand from the state an assurance that perpetrators of sexual offenses and crimes will not get away.


Saturday, October 15, 2016

Can they say YES


I make a humble plea to all. Lets please give permission to our young girls to say yes to sexual intimacy and also lets please give permission to ourselves, the parents, to acknowledge the sexuality of our young girls. Lets not dismiss the truth.  We, they, all are sexual beings.
Two decades ago, an incident of molestation was reported by a young girl from an urban slum community of Delhi. It was part of data collected in a research study undertaken for developing a program on empowerment of adolescent girls. The incident was then put to discussion with young boys and girls from the same community. Interestingly and very revealingly, the boys group unwaveringly related to the situation narrated by the young girl as not of molestation or sexual aggression while the girls group was divided in their opinion. The young boys argued that the girl’s NO meant YES.
The confusion emanates from the societal expectation that girls (and even women) will express interest in, or consent for, sexual intimacy in a coy manner layered in denials and NOs.  No surprise then that the perpetrators of sexual aggression are at best confused about the signals/responses or worse still twist and turn them to suit their own ulterior motives.  Till such time that the girls learn to and have societal permission to say YES their NOs will be left open to interpretation
There is no argument that every NO must be taken at face value irrespective of profile or circumstance of any intimacy initiated or yet to be initiated. However, the ultimate sexual empowerment and liberation of females would lie not only in their ability and sense of joy in saying yes for sexual intimacy but even more so in reaching out for it and pursuing it as something that is to be celebrated and not dreaded.


Monday, March 28, 2016

Ageing......setting of the Sun!
Ageing. Yes, it is for real. Even if one does not look aged. Settled! Setback? Yes. One had hoped, in fact one was sure the make over of youth would be real and one would never age.
Retirement. Yes, again. For real. And yet again one had hoped, in fact believed one would never retire.
Am I ageing because I have retired or have I chosen to retire because I am ageing? Not sure. However, here I am hit by both.
Ageing means lower energy levels, less speed, slower processing of information, slower diction, less sharp, less agile, less bright, sagging of skin and flesh. In nut shell it’s a ‘fading’. It’s the start of the setting of the Sun.  The Sun is becoming less visible and less relevant.
So, as the Sun is getting ready to set and to fade off, what is really happening?
The energy to party is not there. It is lonely! Energy to respond to situations, is not there.  One is less relevant and more dependent! The dreaded word.
Slowness of processing, diction, movement, response means less sharp, interesting, witty, chatty.
Sagging means less beautiful and less noticed.

On the whole, a transition through less visible to invisible. The Sun is setting!